My special friend Bill and I just stayed at Portofino's and absolutely loved it. I would highly recommend either the Jasmine or Sunflower or Honeymoon palapas...
Yes, it is remote, but once you are on the boat to town I don't think it matters if you travel 3 miles or 6 miles to town.
It is romantic, private and very low key. You can always go to town, but when you're not there, you can literally have the pier and the beach to yourself. We loved it!