In January, we'll be staying at Belize Suites, which I understand is just a bit north of town. I've seen bike, water taxi and golf cart (and of course walking) as modes of transportation. Are we close enough to SP to hoof it, or should we plan on renting a cart?

Also, any recommendations for eateries in the area would be deliciously appreciated!

Bike and water taxi. To my knowledge there are no cart rentals up north, and most of the rentals in town really aren't excited about y'all taking the cart across the cut. (Although we do it ALL the time).

Keep in mind, the pull ferry shuts down at 8:00 pm. I spent the night in my golf cart (thats how I know)

For eateries, check here:
//ambergriscaye.com/message/ultimatebb.php?ubb=get_topic;f=4;t=005755