Mike,
Me again. Since last June, I have stayed at Caribe Island, (June), Mayan Princess, (July) Coconuts (Oct during the remodel), Banana Beach, (Nov), Holiday Hotel & Ramons (Dec), and Banana Beach,(Feb.)
Going back later this month on annual vacation with my 13 yr old (this will be his 8th summer in Belize) and he has asked to stay at either Banana Beach or Caribe Island.
Haven't stayed at Banyan Bay (rarely need a two bedroom) but have visited. Our company's accountant stayed for new years and really loved the place. Sorry they are booked.