I just wanted to give a big 4-star review to the Stained Glass Pub. It's fairly new on the island, and I haven't heard anyone mention it. It was AWESOME! Best food we had the whole time we were there (and we went to Caliente, Capricorn, Jambels, Elvi's, etc.). There were 4 of us eating there together, and we each had something different. We each agreed that our meal was the best we had on our vacation. It's a MUST DO when you are there. (No, I have no affiliation with the restaraunt or its owners - it was just THAT good!).
The menu is pretty diverse. Lots of traditional English dishes (fish n chips, meatloaf, shepperd's pie, etc.). My husband had the special - seafood coquis st. jaque. It was to die for. I had the fish specialty (it's on the menu) -- breaded fish in a wonderful wine sauce with capers and artichoke hearts. My friend had the grouper special. I can't remember exactly what it was called, but it had a hollandaise sauce. So good. Then my other friend had fish n chips. Excellent! It's on front street, a little north of Fido's. Great little English pub atmosphere. Small small place, but so great!!!! Friday's were Long Island Iced Tea night. Very yummy.