Well, if a church isn't that important... I figure you could have stayed home to have the wedding inside a church... then you have many options...
I think it boils down to what you like... some people get married right on the beach in front of where they are staying, with their back to the Caribbean... at sunrise... another awesome wedding I saw was a couple that got married at Altun Ha on the grass with the Mayan temple behind them... your options are only limited by your imagination. But don't try to arrange it byself. Go to the experts... there are a few business's on the island that can make all of your arrangements.
You're there to have fun... leave the stress to others.
