Laurie,
While I have never had a massage, I can tell you that Butch swears by Sol Spa. Carrie is wonderful, (and has been known to come to Caribe Island to do in room, or on the beach massages-- we have our own table to make it even easier). If you choose to go to her Spa, it's lovely. Very serene, beautifully decorated, and I've never heard one complaint about Sol Spa (Carrie or her staff), and we have been working with them for over 2 years now.
Cheerz,
Vicki