Two of the resorts you have selected are on North Ambergris.. so you are pretty much limited to the water ferry/taxi whenever you want to commute to 'town'. The road on the north side is not good at the best of times and five miles on a bumpy golf cart is not good for your body. Nite travel on the roads is impossible for those not familiar with the road. Victoria House is much closer to town, you can even walk to town if you wanted to. There are options of renting bikes or golf carts. Using taxis when you stay at Victoria House is another option. Taxis technically do not exist on North Ambergris, although there apparently is one that operates there. Not sure the exact type of vehicle this taxi is and how reliable it is. Locals who live on the north end can perhaps advise.
That being said, all the resorts are good. It just depends on what you really want (quick and easy access to town or seclusion).
I suggest you do a search on this board (trip reports) under each name and see what people have already said.
Which ever resort you pick, be prepared to be bitten by the San Pedro (Ambergris) bug. It gets under your skin and you are itching to return before you even leave...