Thanks for the further recommendations. I've checked out Blue Tang (love the Key West look of this place
) and Mayan Princess and for high season it looks like the prices are in the $165-$170 range. Based on the great recommendations and price, I think at this point I'm leaning towards Woodys.
Seashell, I've read some great things about Amigos for diving ... we could still go with them even if we are staying at Woodys, right?
Again, I appreciate the input!
Beth