Victoria House is about 2 miles south of town. The food and ambiance are superb, although a bit pricey.
El Divino is at Banana Beach, and they have WONDERFUL breakfasts. For a quick breakfast, Monkey Bites at Exotic Caye is perfect.
My favorite lunch place is Caliente's, but I also recently discovered the tacos at Mickeys. YUMMY!!!
But, hands down, Casa Picasso's the SIMPLY THE BEST! The tapas are unforgettable, but save room for dessert! Seriously, the best way to get the whole experience is to go with several people and do round robins----- take a taste and pass it around. The creme brulee is always my favorite, but Colby turned me on to the Kahlua sundae.... and then there is Dee's favorite... Cracked Coconut.
(Jenn and Chris, if you are reading this, I miss you guys. I'm starving!!)
Of course, these places were all ranked second to Ova di Wata, but that is gone (sob, sob).