Thanks, but I'm not really looking to share a bathroom. I'm still debating on where to stay. The Conch Shell is really nice, but way above my budget for the week. I've got quotes in from Martha's (approx $150US/week), and the San Padreno (?) (approx $350US/week). I'd love to be able to upgrade and go with the Conch Shell because it is so much more comfortable than the others, but if I did go more budget off the beach, how easy is it to get access to the beach? I.e. if I'm not staying at any of the beachside hotels, are there still places to lay out and read a book, etc or are those options only available at the hotels (and you have to be staying there to use them)?
Also, I've only been to SP in October... I'm assuming the weather is less unpredictable in mid-January (more sun, less rain)? How about the mosquitos?