My first two visits here I stayed at Paradise Villas - a five minute walk to the center of town but far enough away to be mostly quiet. That is as long as you don't take one of the back units up against the road. Next door is the Blue Tang where I stayed on the 3rd visit and it has been fixed up beautifully. Both these places are in the reasonable price range.
If you are interested in time share or to be left alone then Capt. Morgan's could work. It is beautiful but since the price of gas is so high it costs more to get to town and back.

Harriette
Take only pictures leave only bubbles