http://belizepalms.com/ It appears they are re-building their website!
I have stayed at Exotic Caye the last couple of trips and really like the privacy during the day...but they have an above ground pool.....it doesn't bother me...but might someone else. the Rooms are nice...it's private and there's a little restaurant and great bar steps from your room....check it out your self.
//ambergriscaye.com/playador/index.html