Hi! I've been to Caye Caulker 3 times in the past 15 months and would recommend Tropical Paradise Hotel...south end of Front street. Quiet - great staff - great food - nice beach and pier - varied price range and accomodations...and always clean. I travel alone and have never had any problem with safety...there or anywhere on the island for that matter...although I was usually in my room for the day by 9:00 or 10:00 PM...no laughing!!! The folks at Seaview are also very nice - further south...and depending upon the number in your party and your preferences, the "Banana Cabana"...a rental through "Amanda" is really cool - although last time I was there I saw they had "added on"...kinda spoiled the original quaintness but probably added an opportunity for a "downstairs" rental...just my opinion :-) It's a great place! Have a wonderful time!