We've stayed at both Morningstar and De Real Macaw and enjoyed both places. Morningstar is a couple of blocks away from the water while De Real Macaw is right across the street from a beach. I liked the accomodations better at Morningstar, and it was a really nice, clean, and quiet place and a larger refrigerator. DeReal Macaw was more centralized, but smaller refrigerator and a little noisier. The whole town pretty much quiets down at night so that's not that big of a factor. Bring earplugs if you're worried about noise!